Broach the topic in an unthreatening manner. Leaping out of your closet
with a set of handcuffs, a gigantic strap-on, and a vial of poppers
is, generally speaking, a no-no. Wait for your second date. You want
to choose a time when he's relaxed, post coital, even. Tell him you
want to penetrate him, ask him how he feels about it. Be prepared to
negotiate. 'It doesn't hurt when you do it to me' is a pretty inviolable
position. If he's afraid that it will "make him gay", then
you have two choices: A) Refrain from blowing him, on the same grounds;
or B) Find another boyfriend who isn't such a chowderhead.
Have some information on hand. Tristan
Taormino's new book Pucker up: A Hands-on Guide to Ecstatic Sex
has all the information you'll need to convince a skeptic that anal
play can be safe, clean and satisfying. Lend him your copy if he's bookish;
memorize chapter 6 if he's not.
Promise him something nice, like a fabulous prostate orgasm or a new
pair of pants.
Start slowly, use your fingers and lots of lube. When you think you
have enough lube, add more. You really can't go wrong. The tissue of
the anal cavity is extremely delicate, don't take any chances on hurting
him, or he won't want to play any more reindeer games.
Trim those nails! Taormino gives a really great tip for femmes like
me: stuff some cotton balls into the ends of a latex glove. Voila! My
suggestion is to prepare this in advance, or maybe keep him blindfolded.
Don't want any nasty associations with his yearly checkup.
His prostate is only a few inches inside his ass and towards his navel;
there's no need to traverse the whole pass before nightfall.
Let's be frank: All of this is bound to go over better if you've got
his cock in your mouth.
Added bonus for you! If he orgasms while you've got your fingers in
his bum, you can feel his PC (pubic) muscles repeatedly clench and release,
fast and firm as a conventioneers handshake. Trust me, it is a thing
of beauty.
Once he's comfortable with prostate stimulation, you might want to try
a butt plug instead of a dill. Plugs have a narrow "neck"
and a wide base. This will reduce the stretching of his sphincter, which
some people find irritating. If he wants in-and-out stimulation, then
a dildo is in order. Pick one with a flared base, something smooth and
smallish to begin with. Rome wasn't reamed in a day.
It will probably take some time for both parties to get used to using
a strap-on. The easiest way to start is in the doggie-style position,
or having the penetratee straddle the penetrator. That way the receiver
can control the action and establish a comfortable rhythm. For God's
sake, start subtly and slowly. Porn movies are fiction, people.
Cleanup: Don't share your toys, unless you're able to sterilize them.
It's better to invest in something that's just for him. If you must
share, put a condom on it. This also makes for easy cleanup. Yes, yes,
the mess factor. If he has had a bowel movement and a shower, chances
are you're not going to encounter much, if any, feces. If you do, just
wash your toys with soap and hot water; it's only poo. Remember: Your
mother cleaned up your shit for years and lived to humiliate you in
high school.
And finally: Keep talking, before, during, and after. Anal intercourse
is one of the most intense sexual experiences that humans share, but
it takes time and lots of communication to become adept at it. Unless,
like me, you're a raving ass-gasket. Hey, almost everyone's a natural
at something.